Executive search

Executive search target-company criteria: make the market boundary reviewable

Build a target-company inclusion record with criterion definitions, dated sources, explicit gaps and a client review of the boundary before research expands.

By LaisyPublished

A target-company list is useful when another researcher can explain why a company is on it. A familiar name, a broad industry label or a revenue figure may help with discovery. None of those details, by itself, explains the connection to the client's leadership requirement.

Write the inclusion criteria before the list becomes the working definition of the market. Keep the reason, source and open question beside each decision. That makes it possible to review the boundary with the client and adjust it without treating every earlier choice as settled evidence.

Use the agreed search mandate as the starting point. This guide provides an original company-screening worksheet. It does not prescribe a universal company count, claim complete market coverage or determine whether an individual is suitable for the role.

TL;DR

  • Translate the client's operating requirement into company-context questions the researcher can investigate.
  • Define what each field means, including whether a figure describes a group, subsidiary or relevant business unit.
  • Keep unresolved companies visible with a named question. An empty field is not evidence that a company falls outside the boundary.
  • Review the boundary and research gaps before using the map to explain market coverage to the client.

Start with an inclusion record

Keep the criteria and their application together. The template below can sit in a permitted spreadsheet or an existing research system. Use links to source material where copying it would create unnecessary working copies.

FieldWhat the reviewer needs
CriterionThe company-context question being investigated
Connection to mandateWhy the answer could help identify relevant experience
DefinitionWhat the field includes and excludes
Source and periodWhere the information came from and what period it describes
FindingThe observed fact, stated separately from interpretation
Boundary statusIn scope for research, unresolved or outside the agreed scope
ReasonThe evidence and instruction supporting that status
Open questionWhat could change the decision
Review ownerWho will check the answer or seek client clarification

Write the criterion definitions once, then link company records to that version. If a definition changes, record which decisions may need review. Keep the previous reasoning available rather than silently replacing the basis of an earlier exclusion.

Connect the company question to the work the leader must do

Ask the client which operating experiences matter and why. A broad phrase such as “complex business” needs clarification before it becomes a research filter. The relevant complexity could involve customers, ownership, geography, manufacturing, regulation or a specific change the organization is planning.

For federal assessment, OPM's job-analysis guidance connects job tasks with required competencies. Use that organizing distinction to clarify the brief. The company worksheet is an original research aid, not a validated assessment method or a universal executive-search standard.

Translate the explanation into a question a source could help answer. If the client needs experience coordinating several operating units, the question might concern the organization of those units. A large group revenue figure may not answer it. Keep the required experience and the available company evidence separate.

Also record where company context stops being informative. A person can work within a relevant business without having held the responsibilities the mandate requires. Treat the map as a way to direct research, with individual evidence reviewed later.

Define the fields before comparing the companies

Make ambiguous field names explicit. For “size,” state the measure, the relevant organizational level and the period. For “sector,” describe the activity that matters to the assignment. For “geography,” distinguish where a company sells from where the relevant operation is managed.

These definitions do not have to be elaborate. They need to prevent a researcher from comparing unlike information without noticing. If comparable evidence is unavailable, record that limitation instead of filling the field with a convenient substitute.

Use a small permitted sample to test the definitions. Ask a second researcher to apply them and explain the difficult cases. Review disagreements about meaning before expanding the list. This is a consistency exercise for the research process, not a claim that two reviewers have validated candidate suitability.

Keep the definitions tied to the current brief version. An adjacent-market request may change the company boundary, the evidence needed or both. Identify that effect before adding new names.

Check completeness and accuracy separately

A fully populated sheet can still contain the wrong organizational level, an outdated source or an interpretation presented as a fact. Check whether each field is useful for the specific research question, rather than treating filled cells as proof of quality.

The UK Government Data Quality Framework describes six core dimensions and distinguishes completeness from accuracy. It also treats the relevant quality priorities as context dependent. Here, use the framework as a reference for asking better questions about research records, not as a certification checklist.

For each consequential finding, retain a source pointer and the period it covers. Note when the source is a company statement, a filing, a news account or another kind of record. A recent publication can describe an earlier reporting period; both dates may matter.

If an answer comes from an inference, label the reasoning and what remains unconfirmed. Keep that approach consistent with the candidate research-note structure when the company context is later used in an individual record.

Use an unresolved status deliberately

An unresolved company can be valuable research work. It tells the team which part of the boundary cannot yet be applied and what information would help. Give the question an owner and a proposed way to resolve it.

Keep contact restrictions separate from research relevance. A company can be relevant to investigate while a contact instruction remains restricted; preserve both boundaries.

Use a reason that supports a next action. “Not enough information” is less useful than “the available source describes the group, while the criterion concerns the operating division.” The latter points to a specific evidence gap and a possible clarification with the client.

Avoid allowing unresolved entries to drift into whichever group makes the report easier to present. They should remain distinguishable when the list is filtered, exported or handed to another colleague. Check that the explanation survives those operations.

If the client accepts a broader proxy for discovery, record that agreement and its limit. An accepted discovery proxy does not establish that every resulting company or individual meets the final requirement.

Synthetic example: a company list with a visible boundary

This example is fictional. Its company labels and counts demonstrate the worksheet; they are not market research, a recommended list size or customer results.

A search team reviews 12 example companies against an agreed operating-context question. The client wants the research to investigate a particular kind of operating responsibility, while allowing a limited adjacent-sector exploration.

Example groupCountReview outcome
Companies A–G7Enough relevant company-context evidence to continue research
Companies H–J3Available material does not resolve the agreed question
Companies K–L2Outside the client's current research boundary, with reasons recorded

The counts total 12. They describe this invented review only. The seven companies are starting points for further work; their inclusion does not assess any person. The three unresolved records stay visible with questions and owners.

For Company H, the available source covers the parent group. The record explains that the operating-unit question remains open. For Company I, the relevant information describes an earlier organizational structure. The researcher records the period and seeks a suitable current source.

Company K falls outside the current boundary, but the consultant identifies a question that could justify asking the client about adjacent experience. That question is recorded as a proposal. The researcher does not quietly change the definition to include it.

Check the existing research tools before duplicating work

Review which information and filters the firm's existing system already provides. For example, Clockwork's rediscovery documentation describes past-search filters including industry and company size. That is Clockwork's documentation; it is not a claim about a Laisy connector or capability.

If earlier assignments offer relevant company context, review their original scope and source dates before reuse. The candidate rediscovery workflow makes a similar distinction between previous knowledge and current evidence. Past relevance can direct attention without settling the new question.

Choose where the approved criteria and current statuses will live. If a working sheet is necessary, identify its owner and how reviewed findings return to the existing record. Avoid leaving two apparently authoritative maps with different definitions.

Review the map with the client

Show the boundary, its rationale and the unresolved questions. Ask about the specific cases that challenge the agreed definition. The discussion should help the client understand what the research has established and where a decision or further evidence is still needed.

For member engagements, the AESC Client Bill of Rights includes ongoing communication about market response and search progress. Use that as a professional reference, with its member scope clear. The proposed company review is not an AESC requirement for every assignment.

Carry the relevant coverage limitations into the next client update. State the research boundary and outstanding questions in plain language. A count of reviewed companies alone cannot establish that the whole market has been covered.

After the discussion, record any approved definition change and identify affected work. Ask the next research owner to explain the current boundary and one unresolved case. That readback can reveal ambiguity before more work is built on it.

Try a bounded company-context review

Select a small, suitable part of a real assignment and agree the permitted inputs. Decide in advance what a useful reviewed record would contain: understandable criteria, traceable sources, honest gaps and clear follow-up ownership.

You can discuss that task with Laisy alongside the tools you already use. Agree the output review and the point to continue or stop. Keep any broader market coverage, product capability or research result as something to establish, not a promise made by the pilot framing.

Frequently asked questions

How many companies should be in the map?

Choose the scope with the client and explain its rationale. This guide offers no universal count. The relevant market, mandate, evidence availability and research boundary determine what work is useful; a larger list alone does not demonstrate better coverage.

Can group revenue stand in for business-unit size?

Only use a proxy with its meaning and limits clear. Record the organizational level and period. If the criterion concerns a division, group data may leave the question unresolved and require further research or client clarification.

How should adjacent sectors be handled?

Record why they might offer relevant experience and obtain an agreed research boundary. Keep exploratory inclusion distinguishable from confirmed relevance. A sector label does not establish an individual's responsibilities or evidence.

Can AI decide which companies are in scope?

Any suggested classification needs review against the agreed definition and supporting sources. Keep uncertain findings visible and retain human responsibility for the research boundary. This guide does not claim that Laisy automatically classifies companies.